ILM Blog – The Opportunities and Challenges of Legacy Income: Why Consistency Matters
October 5, 2026Legacy income for UK charities reached an estimated £4.4 billion in 2025*, making it one of the most significant and fastest-growing income streams across the charitable sector. For many organisations, legacies now represent a substantial proportion of annual income and, in some cases, their largest single source of revenue.
Paul Browne, the ILM’s Head Of Professional Standards, discusses why understanding, forecasting and accounting for legacy income has become a critical financial management issue.

The importance of this issue is heightened by the introduction of the new SORP 2026, which brings changes to the way legacy income is recognised and reported. While the technical accounting implications may be relatively modest for many charities, the wider challenge remains unchanged: how can charities provide meaningful, reliable and comparable information about an income stream that is inherently uncertain?
The strategic importance of legacy income
Charities are operating in an increasingly volatile environment. Economic uncertainty, changing donor behaviour, inflationary pressures and evolving patterns of public giving all reinforce the need for diversified and resilient income streams. Yet for many charities, legacy income has grown to such an extent that diversification itself becomes a challenge.
Where legacies account for a significant proportion of total income, trustees and senior management need a clear understanding of both current performance and future expectations. Strategic decisions about service delivery, investment, reserves and workforce planning increasingly depend on confidence in legacy forecasts.
This places considerable importance on the quality of information presented within the legacy pipeline. Boards need to understand not only what has been received, but also what is expected to be received, over what timeframe, and with what level of certainty. Effective forecasting therefore becomes essential.
The challenge of comparability
Given the significance of legacy income, it would be reasonable to assume that charities account for and forecast it in a largely consistent way. In practice, this has not historically been the case.
The difficulty arises because legacy administration is complex. Every estate is different and charities must exercise judgement when assessing entitlement, valuation certainty, timing and collectability. These factors make it challenging to create a single approach that works equally well for all organisations.
A review of major charity accounts highlights this issue. Charities with comparable levels of legacy dependence can report very different relationships between recognised income and outstanding legacy debtors. At first glance, such differences might suggest variations in operational efficiency or collection performance. However, a closer examination often reveals something more fundamental: they are recognising legacy income at different points in the estate administration process.
In other words, the figures may not be measuring the same thing.
One charity may recognise a legacy once probate has been granted and sufficient information is available to estimate value reliably. Another may wait until estate accounts are received. A third may use receipt of a first distribution as the primary trigger for recognition. Each approach can potentially comply with accounting requirements and withstand audit scrutiny, provided the associated judgements are reasonable and appropriately disclosed.
The result is that two charities can report materially different debtor positions even where the underlying estates look remarkably similar.
Why this matters
Accounting policy differences do not necessarily imply poor practice. Transparent disclosure and consistency within an organisation remain fundamental principles of good financial reporting. Auditors rightly focus on whether a charity’s chosen approach is appropriate and consistently applied year after year.
However, sector-wide inconsistency creates wider problems.
Trustees, regulators, funders, analysts and other stakeholders increasingly seek to compare financial performance across organisations. Legacy income is now sufficiently important that differing recognition policies can significantly distort those comparisons. A reported debtor balance in one charity may reflect estates at a much earlier stage of administration than a similar balance reported elsewhere. Likewise, annual income figures may be influenced as much by accounting policy as by underlying legacy performance.
As legacy income continues to grow in strategic importance, comparable reporting becomes increasingly valuable.
The key judgement: when should a legacy be recognised?
The central challenge is determining the point at which a legacy should be recognised.
Most charities would agree that neither extreme is desirable. Recognising legacies far too early introduces significant risk that estimates will prove inaccurate. Recognising them only when cash is received effectively moves toward a cash-accounting approach, undermining the core principles of accruals accounting.
The debate therefore centres on where the appropriate balance should be struck.
Probate often represents the first significant milestone. Once probate has been granted and no disputes or competing claims are apparent, entitlement may appear reasonably clear. The remaining challenge becomes valuation. Should income be recognised based on initial estate information, adjusted for anticipated costs and future market movements? Or should recognition wait until estate accounts provide greater certainty?
Reasonable professionals can arrive at different answers.
From an audit perspective, there is naturally concern about premature recognition. Income recognised too early may subsequently require adjustment if asset values change, liabilities emerge, or administrative issues delay settlement. Equally, delayed recognition may fail to reflect the underlying economic reality of the charity’s position.
The challenge is particularly acute because legacy income often involves estimates rather than precise measurements. Property values may fluctuate. Tax liabilities and estate expenses may change. Investment values can move significantly during administration. All of these factors require judgement.
Materiality and scale
Materiality adds a further layer of complexity.
Large charities administering substantial portfolios of legacies are often able to rely on historic experience when estimating costs, valuation movements and collection outcomes. Across a large volume of estates, estimation errors may broadly offset each other over time.
Smaller charities face a different challenge. With fewer cases in progress, a single estate can have a disproportionate impact on reported results. Statistical assumptions become less reliable, and each judgement carries greater significance. What may be an immaterial estimation difference for a major national charity could be highly material for a smaller organisation.
This inevitably raises questions about whether the same practical approach can be applied across organisations of vastly different sizes and complexity.
The timing challenge
Timing remains another important consideration.
Although probate delays have eased compared with the significant backlogs seen in recent years, the time between probate and receipt of funds can still be substantial. Estates involving property sales, complex investments or contentious administration may take many months, and sometimes years, to conclude.
Where expected receipt is significantly delayed, finance teams must consider whether discounting becomes relevant and how such adjustments should be estimated. Again, larger organisations may have sufficient historic data to support portfolio-based assumptions, while smaller charities may have limited evidence on which to base judgements.
These practical difficulties help explain why consistent treatment has proven challenging to achieve across the sector.
The case for greater consistency
Despite these challenges, greater consistency remains both achievable and desirable.
Legacy income has moved beyond being a specialist issue relevant only to legacy administration teams. It now plays a major role in financial planning, risk management and strategic decision-making across the charity sector. The quality and comparability of reporting therefore matter more than ever.
The objective should not necessarily be to determine the theoretically earliest or latest acceptable point of recognition. Instead, the priority should be identifying an approach that can be applied consistently across the sector, enabling stakeholders to interpret financial information with confidence.
There will always be room for professional judgement. Factors such as materiality, estate complexity and the quality of available evidence mean that no framework can eliminate judgement entirely. Nevertheless, stronger guidance can narrow the range of acceptable interpretations and improve comparability.
For finance professionals, consistency delivers significant benefits. Forecasts have become more meaningful. Benchmarking has become more reliable. Trustees gain greater confidence when making strategic decisions. External stakeholders can better understand the financial position of charities across the sector.
Looking ahead
The introduction of SORP 2026 provides an opportunity to revisit how legacy income is recognised, measured, and communicated. While there will undoubtedly continue to be debate around the precise point of recognition, the broader objective should be clear: ensuring that legacy reporting is transparent, understandable and as far as possible, comparable.
Legacy income is simply too important to be reported in ways that make meaningful comparison difficult. As the sector becomes increasingly dependent on this vital source of funding, finance professionals, auditors, trustees and legacy specialists all have a role to play in promoting greater consistency.
The challenges are real, but they are not insurmountable. If the sector can move towards a more consistent approach, the result will be better forecasting, better decision-making and stronger financial stewardship of one of charities’ most valuable assets.
If you would like to learn more about the intricacies of Legacy accounting, the Institute of Legacy Management’s new Financial Essentials course is open for bookings to both members and non-members. Find out more here: In Focus: Financial Essentials for Legacy Management | Institute Of Legacy Management
*Source: Legacy Futures Legacy Giving Report 2026, as referenced in the original article.
Tags
Feature, Good Practice, ILM news, Legacy news, News, Opinion, Uncategorized
Discuss
Post in the forum (members only)
Mention on Twitter